Blog

What a “Shark” Looks For When They’re Hiring People

If there’s one thing I love about the television show Shark Tank, it’s getting insights into how uber-smart and savvy entrepreneurs think.

If you’ve ever seen the show — and it’s on in a terrible time slot Friday nights — you know that, according to Wikipedia, it “shows aspiring entrepreneur-contestants as they make business presentations to a panel of ‘shark’ investors, who then choose whether or not to invest.”

That’s the basic premise of the show, but for me, the real insight comes from watching “sharks” like Mark Cuban, Lori Greiner and Daymond John decide whether or not they want to invest in some new product or business based on just a small of information gleaned from needy and aspiring entrepreneurs making a pitch.

What a savvy business executive looks for in people

Barbara Corcoran, of ABC’s “Shark Tank”

I love the back and forth between “sharks” and contestants, and that’s why I was intrigued with an interview that “shark” Barbara Corcoran, an entrepreneur and judge on Shark Tank, did with The New York Times‘ Adam Bryant and his weekly Corner Office column. In it, Corcoran gives something you don’t get a lot of on Shark Tank — insight into what she looks for when she’s hiring people.

Here’s what she told The Times:

When I hire people, I just look for the light in the person, to see what’s good about them. I can spot it a mile away. And I never read a résumé until after the interview because you never know who wrote it, and you can be fooled by it. If you read a résumé, the interview is nothing but a business small-talk session confirming stuff you just read.

So I’ll just ask: “What do you like? Tell me about your mom. Where did you grow up? What’s your hobby? What was your favorite job? Why?”

I’m also trying to figure out if they’re happy, because unhappy people don’t accomplish a lot. I’m also looking for their energy, and if they’re going to be able to see the possibility in anything I propose. Those are the major cards. They cover 90 percent of successful people in the workplace.”

3 Key Qualities to look for

This is interesting because it’s always good when you can get into what a super successful businesswoman like Barbara Corcoran believes is important in finding out during a job interview. Here’s my recap on what she asks:

  1. Focus on what lights up a person and dig into what is good about them;
  2. Don’t read the resume until AFTER the interview. If you read it before you talk to them, you don’t get a lot of additional insight because all it tends to do is reconfirm what you have already read.
  3. Does the person show a lot of energy? Are they happy? Do they see the possibilities in life and in business? These are key traits in most successful people.

Although you may be looking for some other specific qualities when you interview a candidate, this is great advice on what you might want to have underpinning your overall discussion. With these three items, you should be able to really drill into whether a candidate is right for you and your organization — or not.

A question you should always ask

But, that’s not all that “shark” Barbara  Corcoran told The New York Times. Here’s how she responded to the question, “If you could ask somebody only one question in a job interview, what would it be?”

(I’d ask,) tell me about your family. If their family couldn’t give them a positive attitude, there’s nothing I can do that’s going to change it. Early on, I hired a couple of people who had all the markings of great salespeople, but they were not happy people.

I learned that if you have just one unhappy person in a pool of 30 happy people, you feel that weight. I couldn’t wait to get them in my office to tell them they had to leave. I loved firing complainers.”

There it is again; she wants to know about your family and get a sense of whether you are a positive person or not. If you’re not happy, positive, and upbeat, she doesn’t want you as part of her team.

Yes, yes, I know that it’s not that hard for someone to “act” happy in a job interview, or to project a positive demeanor when they’re hardly positive at all. I also know that there are certain jobs that attract people who aren’t naturally happy — like engineers — who actually can do some pretty good work without really showing much of that quality.

My guess is that if you asked Barbara Corcoran about this that she would tell you that the more you focus on happiness and positivity in job interviews, the more you will be able to drill into people about it and the more likely it is you will be able to tell when someone really IS happy and when someone is not.

Figuring out what is important for your team

The key is this: If you have certain qualities you look for that are important to you, your business, and your team, you’ll be able to have a meaningful discussion with job candidates about them. And, you’ll be able to figure out whether the candidate truly exhibits those qualities, or not.

This is the key to deciding whether to pull the trigger on hiring a person, and it’s as important for a “shark” deciding whether to take a chance on a product pitch as it is for a recruiter or talent manager trying to figure out if a candidate they’re interviewing would be a good fit on your team.

What are YOUR key qualities that you look for in a job interview? Knowing those are important to making smart hires, and if you aren’t sure, you could do worse than to use Barbara Corcoran’s questions to guide you. After all, who wouldn’t want to take hiring advice from a TV “shark?”

The Five: Video Interview Software Tools You Need to Try

Ideally, we want to meet every candidate in-person before submitting to a hiring manager. But, in the name of time and cost, conducting a video interview is often a better alternative. So the question then becomes, “Should I use a video interviewing software or just use something like Skype?” The answer is hands down, use a video interviewing software. Here is why.

Simple video chat software or tools like Skype or Google Hangouts were not made for video interviewing. The best part about using interviewing software is it’s ability to reduce bias in hiring. And, using it will allow all hiring managers and others in the recruiting process to have a chance to see the candidates response to important questions because of the fact that you can record the video and share with the team.

Of course, there are a number of video interviewing software platforms available and they are all a bit different than the next. Here are the five we think you should review:

HireVue

HireVue is well known for its video interviewing technology. But, they also are trailblazers when it comes to machine learning and artificial intelligence. They use this cutting edge technology to analyze how a candidate talks, their phrasing and even their body language. It takes this data and cross references it against current successful employees. When we (RecruitingDaily) first saw that they had this capability, we immediately reached out to HireVue to see if it is true. Well, it is. They truly have the experts and the science backing up the data and the product. We will be at their user conference and will be sharing the latest that HireVue has to offer soon. Click here and try for yourself.

 

https://youtu.be/hE1dBI01FfU

Spark Hire

Spark Hire calls itself the “Simple” video interviewing software. At $49, this is pretty affordable. They also have several candidate experience and engagement tools such as rejection management, custom welcome videos and social media integration. Last year they launched a scheduling tool to make a recruiter’s life a bit easier.

“As any recruiter or hiring manager knows, scheduling a job interview often takes more time than the interview itself,” said Josh Tolan, CEO at Spark Hire. “Our new scheduler eliminates the back-and-forth of picking a time that works for both parties. You email a personalized link and candidates select which open times in your schedule also works for them.”

Click here to try Spark Hire.

 

WePow

WePow connects recruiters, job candidates and employers through easy-to-use mobile and video interviewing solutions. “Our mission is and always has been to make the recruitment process simpler, more personal and more productive — for employers and candidates alike. This is our promise to our customers and remains our ultimate focus,” said Imo Udom, co-founder, and CEO of WePow. “Our new logo maintains the essence of the previous logo while further recognizing the importance of the relationship between our customers and the internal team that serves them.” We especially like the candidate messaging capabilities.

 

 

 

HackerRank

If you thought HackerRank was just a place to source candidates, you thought wrong. HackerRank also has video interviewing software more powerful than most. In addition to video interviewing it allows you to watch a candidate code in real-time using “CodePair.” You can also record the interview so that all involved in the hiring process can all see the same thing. Click here to try for yourself.

 

InterviewStream

The company’s web-based solutions include live video interviewing solutions; pre-recorded interviewing solutions; and InterviewStream 360, a practice interview system that enables job seekers to see and hear themselves online. It also provides Video Interview Branded Experience, a video interviewing tool that offers video-based questions and texts. The company’s online technology provides video interview solutions to employers; and executive search, staffing, and career transition firms internationally.

 

https://youtu.be/_T6TcKxn0Bw

 

 

Software is Eating the World: The Challenge in Finding and Keeping Developers

Technical talent comes at a premium, and the market for skilled developers is going to continue to heat up. Traditional business models are being upended by software solutions.

Take the auto industry as an example: If you purchase a car in 2017, chances are there were more software engineers than mechanical engineers involved in bringing that car to market. This means that almost every organization with a long-term orientation needs to become very good at attracting and retaining developers in order to thrive.

The competition for talent is fierce. Sophisticated technical skills are in constant demand, and new start-ups are absorbing the best and brightest candidates right out of school. As these organizations scale, they need to keep growing their staff in order to build more product better and faster.

So, in order to hire and retain this top talent, you need to understand the reasons people want to join, what keeps them happy in their jobs, and what might trigger an employee to leave.

Who do developers like to work with?

  • As a rule, developers like to work with other smart people – people who can understand and appreciate the problems they are trying to solve and who have an enthusiasm for challenging work. A great development manager hires people who are smarter than them, without feeling threatened by the accomplishments of their team.
  • Developers also thrive in a respectful environment. They prefer to work with people who are helpful and cooperative. While there is plenty of room for quirkiness and idiosyncrasies, disrespect and harassment can quickly poison a team.
  • A talented developer is often at their best when they work for a respected company that treats its employees well, surrounded by friends and former classmates or colleagues.

What kind of work motivates developers?

As cliché as it may sound, developers seek to change the world. They are looking for opportunities to apply their considerable skills and education to problems that have real-life impact.

When a developer reviews a potential employer, the mission matters – possibly more than anything else. Developers will gravitate to organizations that give them the opportunity to build useful products and services.

Most developers want to understand how their contributions are going to make a difference, and that what they have built will endure. Furthermore, developers are hardwired to seek new and interesting projects. They are driven by an innate need to solve problems, and solve them completely.

Communicating the novelty, challenge, and importance of the work being done can go a long way to attracting a skilled candidate.

How do developers like to work?

It’s well established that developers expect to earn based on their value and contribution. In most cases, this requires a combination of competitive salary and appropriate equity in the venture they’ve joined (commensurate with risk, experience and value). A compensation package that offers the right incentive mix is one of the best ways to align a developer for long-term employment with an organization.

Once they’ve bought in to the mission and vision of the company, ensure that they can see how spectacular effort can translate into a spectacular outcome for them, personally.

Developers also like to be able to adapt to the changing technology landscape. If they are working for a company that is slow to adopt new technology, or is unwilling to take risks in innovation, they may grow bored or dissatisfied in their role and begin to look for more bleeding-edge challenges elsewhere.

Ensure developers have the opportunity to keep learning and applying new skills and knowledge in their role to keep them happy in the long term.

Many developers have also adopted a particular work style that suits them well – some combination of close teamwork in an office space and independent work from home or elsewhere when required. In addition to providing employees with the flexibility they need to manage their personal lives, this approach can often help maximize individual productivity.

Focus on what it is that motivates developers

Remember, developers are motivated by the challenge and have “bought in” to the mission. Engaged employees will go above and beyond to contribute even when they are away from their desks.

Over the next several years, most businesses will become technology companies of some sort in order to remain competitive. Growth and change are never easy, but any employer that takes the time to truly understand what motivates developers – and builds those factors into their culture – will be rewarded with a sharper competitive edge, increased ability to scale, relevance in a changing world and a vibrant culture that employees are happy to be a part of.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Ozzie Goldschmied is Chief Technology Officer at Ceridian – a leading human capital management technology company – where he spearheads all Research and Development and Product Management functions while focusing on best practices, excellence and innovation in product delivery. Prior to Ceridian, Ozzie was a founding member of Dayforce and Senior Vice President of Engineering. He was instrumental in leading the design and development of Dayforce HCM, the award-winning single application for human capital management.  Connect with him on LinkedIn.

Recruiting GI Joe – What Recruiters Need to Know

Why did I headline this article with this phrase “Recruiting GI Joe?”  If you need to recruit veterans and don’t realize the negative connotation of the title, then it will behoove you to read on.

Terms like PCS. ETS. NCO — do you know what these stand for and what they mean? Do you know what Terminal Leave is? No, it’s NOT medical leave for someone who is dying.

If you have not grown up in or around the military, chances are you are not even aware of what uniformed personnel actually do for a living. If you do not understand the context of the role or the branch of the military, you will not be able to translate the highly desirable “military” skills and suitability for your company that our members of the military possess.

But, back to this article’s headline. I chose it for the shock value, because unfortunately, it is SHOCKING how many recruiters, when they see “U.S. Army” on a resume, have images of the last movie they saw in which armed military gunned down innocents in a village.

Things about veterans that recruiters should know

If this is you, please read or watch Band of Brothers, which tells of American soldiers escaping from hospitals to rejoin their teammates on Military Help Wantedthe battlefield. This is based on true, historical accounts. Would you do this to help your teammates who are in the trenches with an urgent hiring requisition? Would you personally respond to candidates while in a hospital recovery room? Yes, I have done this.

You cannot discriminate against veterans, but what about your internal bias? In speaking with recruiters, I have found that most have a “Fear of the Unknown,” or “Don’t understand it, so will simply swipe left.”

Here are some things you should know. But, you don’t have to take MY word for it! (Special shout out to LeVar Burton on Reading Rainbow.) After speaking with Karen Hunter about veteran job tips for Military Appreciation Month on SiriusXM  Urban View, I was deluged by thanks from veterans for sharing spot-on tips for them.

I then asked this question: “If you could give recruiters ONE tip for recruiting you, what would it be?”  What follows is a compilation of their input, and my hope is that it will help you to understand how to more effectively recruit veterans, thereby becoming better at your craft and successful in connecting great talent with great positions in great companies.

Attributes that veterans bring to the table

Let’s start with some of the required attributes. But first, a caveat.

Just as there are “bad cops,” “bad teachers,” “bad nurses,” etc., not everyone who served in the military possesses all the positive traits you want. The myth that some people believe is that if you are “bad” you get a dishonorable discharge.

Truth be told, many are not permitted to re-enlist because they did not maintain the high standards of their position or the basic requirements for military service. A military orchestra member was late a few times, and forgot his uniform for one concert. He was not permitted to re-enlist, but received an honorable discharge.

Now, just a few of the great attributes:

  • Chain of command — Nearly all veterans understand how to work under supervision, and have learned skills on how to work under bad supervisors or supervisors who micromanaged every detail of their work. They were required to demonstrate respect, even when in disagreement. This is a life skill I wish could be taught before anyone graduates from high school!
  • Team player — There are few, if any, military roles that do not require working in a team, collaborating with other teams, and seeking to execute on tasks where one’s life could depend on someone else’s competence. There are few “Lone Ranger” positions, which means that, at the very least, the veteran has learned to flex, adapt, and cooperate with diverse individuals.
  • Being on time — Punctuality is not optional. In the military, excuses for traffic, weather, failed alarm clocks, etc., simply do not exist.
  • Preparedness — Having all of the proper gear in working order and understanding specific processes becomes rote. Imagine a team member who ensures that everything that is necessary to execute on task and on time comes to work at your company every day!
  • Rapid response — In many positions, life-or-death circumstances dictate the imperativeness of being focused, always aware of one’s surroundings, and being trained to think logically and act confidently. This is an exemplary skill to navigate competing deadlines and/or a change of direction.
  • Humility — This is, perhaps, one of the most important qualities of which you, as a recruiter, need to be aware. Military personnel have confided in me time and again that it is instilled in them to not brag, not to showboat, or draw personal attention to themselves. In short, you must ask probing questions because chances are, many phenomenal accomplishments (you’ll also learn about the more military term “successes”) have not been disclosed in the resume, and certainly not on their LinkedIn profile.

Here is where you do not ask, “What is your proudest career accomplishment to date?”  If you are still asking these type of questions, my suggestion is to start reading more blogposts to update your relevance to this particular decade.

Instead, ask this: “Tell me about some of the most memorable successes that you and your team achieved.”  The comfort level in speaking about the team’s successes will facilitate a greater ease for the veteran in relaying the information you are seeking.

You MUST be “veteran-friendly”

Some more detailed explanations…

“When can you start?”  

Let’s start with “Terminal Leave” and “Permissive TDY”.  It is important to note that the, “When can you start?” answer can depend on Military to Veteran to Civilianwhether a person is retiring or separating. For example, if officers are on terminal leave, they may be able to start during that time if the position is in a different location. In federal contracting, one cannot be sent back into the same building as a civilian unless one has already ETSed (Expiration of Term of Service – officially no longer in the military).

“What is your current salary?”

Your job is to figure out their current compensation with them. There is non-taxable income, indicating approximately 25% more take-home pay. Medical, dental and vision is paid for, so no co-insurance and nearly no out of pocket medical expenses. There is a housing allowance. There is a food allowance. Are you now seeing how the “current salary question” is not applicable to transitioning/transitioned members of the military?

There is an excellent Military-to-Civilian calculator that can assist you – and I suggest using it early on in the recruiting process for personal and organizational education. In fact, most veterans simply do not know their market value in the civilian world, so DO NOT take advantage of them by low-balling their salary. In fact, please don’t do this with anyone you are vetting.

In order to #RecruitHuman, you must treat others as you would like to be treated. One major way you can serve veterans is by helping them to assess the salary range that they should be targeting, commensurate with their translatable skills. Do this and they’ll tell their friends, and quite likely will positively brand your company as “veteran-friendly.”

I just read a posting on LinkedIn from a retiring lieutenant colonel. His lament? He was turned down for an IT position because he had “too much” management experience.

Put on your talent sleuthing hat and make inquiries about his/her actual experiences. In transition classes, officers are told to emphasize their managerial skills, and when you look at their experience in personnel, budgets, logistics, etc., it is impressive! You need to know how many people are in which reference unit.

Assessing a veteran’s managerial experience

Although the U.S. Army has not officially used these designators since World War II, you will see these terms on resumes. Depending upon the size of the unit, someone will have varying degrees of operational, organizational and financial accountability in very much the same way a person will have when performing the role in a non-military environment.

The information below is derived from an Army Operational Unit Diagram:

  • Squad/section: 4 to 10 soldiers;
  • Platoon: 3 to 4 squads/sections of 16 – 44 soldiers;
  • Company/battery/troop: 3 to 5 platoons of 60 – 200 soldiers;
  • Battalion/squadron: 4 to 6 companies of 300 – 1,000 soldiers;
  • Brigade/regiment: 2 to 5 battalions of 1,500 – 3,200 soldiers;
  • Division: 3 brigades of 10,000 – 16,000 soldiers;
  • Corps: 2 to 5 divisions of 20,000 – 45,000 soldiers;
  • Field army: 2 plus corps of 50,000 plus soldiers.

These details are provided so that you can understand, contextually, what you are reading on a veteran’s resume. Some of us have never even been on a team of 50,000 plus people, much less have had responsibility for the execution of their tasks, their personal health and welfare, the logistics, the supplies, etc.

Officers and NCOs (Non-Commissioned Officers) work in tandem to achieve the goals and objectives. Do not let rank fool you! The sergeant major may have carried greater responsibility for the outworking of the directives than the OIC (Officer-in-Charge). Higher ranking does not always mean more depth of expertise/experience. There are also other variables at play here. Only a certain number of applicants (those who enlisted prior to college or college graduation) are accepted into Officer Candidate School (OCS). This does not mean that those who were not accepted are less qualified or should be less regarded than a higher ranking person. Other factors dictate rank progression, so again, do not judge a person based on final rank.

More terms you should know

  • MOS (Military Occupational Specialty) — One attends a specialized school after basic training. When you see this on a resume, it tells you what career path was at the onset of the career, but you need to evaluate career progression to see if the person stayed the course or deviated from it. I spoke with someone at a career fair who had 7 by the end of her career. If there is a deviation, that is a great interview question! Make an inquiry, and find out if they followed their passions, or if there was another compelling reason for the change.
  • PCS (Permanent Change of Station). What this means for you: if you are in Austin, and someone is in Washington, DC, chances are they are applying to your position because they are having their final move paid for. This means you will not have to pay for relocation! I know recruiters who had no clue about this and rejected out of state candidates for this reason. Not you, though, because now you know! USAA has a comprehensive guide to Permanent Change of Station and can be found here.

Look for reasons to rule them in, not out

Not all resumes are going to be written with your position in mind. Many will list every duty station, sometimes as separate positions. Do your best to read between the lines, and if you do not see what you are looking for or do not understand what you are reading, set up a phone screen. It is always better to clarify than to overlook. Keep finding reasons to rule people in, not out.

Acclimation is an issue, too

Now, about a lack of knowledge of “the way things work.” If you live near a military base or post, contact the SFL-TAP (Soldier for Life — Transition Assistance Program), and here are links for TAPS to each branch of the military:

Ask to take the Director to lunch. Prepare a list of questions to help you to know who you are targeting, what to do when you find them, how to understand what they have done, and what assistance they will need from you to determine viability for your company and/or your positions. Also, remember to pay for the lunch!

Finally, you have successfully hired a veteran. Congratulations! Does your company have a retention plan in place?

Yeah, about that. It is great to provide veterans their first civilian job in a while (for some, after 20 plus years), but this transition will be a culture shock. If your company is not located in a military-centric part of the country, many support services may not be available to your veterans.

Just as you had a million questions about how to convert military terms into civilian-ese, veterans may not have had exposure to many current terms and jargon that we take for granted. It’s up to you to extend your normal onboarding program into a year-long acclimation program for veterans.

Also, they may have to hang out at “acronym finder” sites to know what everyone is LOLing about on the Slack channel. Make it easy for them to identify when they are not “getting” something, and to provide a safe environment within which they can ask questions and get great, non-judgmental support.

Successful hiring and onboarding veterans

Have a “mentor” who checks in daily for the first few weeks, twice a week for a few weeks, and once a week for at least until the 90-day mark. When I first moved to Utah, I didn’t know the lingo, didn’t understand the customs (like Trunk or Treat), didn’t know what was appropriate and not appropriate in terms of inviting my child’s classmates to the house, etc. I befriended my neighbor, who gave me tutorials on the culture, was there for any random question I might have, and I watched a few videos. Without her, I probably would not have made it through those initial few months.  Let’s make sure we all have “buddy systems” in place to ensure great employee engagement, team building, and the “R” word of the day: RETENTION!

Remember: Do not hire veterans because, “It is the right thing to do.”  You should hire great veterans so that you can leverage those years of experience and training, stellar work ethics, and proven character to make great contributions to your company.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Jo Weech is the Chief People Officer at Anthem Engineering. She also started Exemplary Consultants to assist start ups and small businesses solidify infrastructure with everything from HR to Operations. An organizational zealot, Jo enjoys new methodology, technology, and new challenges. She teaches a four week class on how to project manage your life and organize your living/working spaces for optimal efficiency. She also speaks to local career transition groups, career panels, career fairs, universities, and ETAP/TAP/RTAP classes for military transition. Follow her on Twitter @JoWeech and connect with her on LinkedIn.

Dodging a Bullet: How to Avoid the Candidate From Hell

When it comes to hiring, just about every experienced recruiter and talent manager has a story about the great candidate that turned out to be not so great.

You know what I’m talking about: Top notch candidates with incredible resumes who seem too good to be true who ARE too good to be true and actually turn out to be a nightmare.

When you hear people talking about them, it’s generally in the context of “Hey, you can’t believe the one that I was lucky enough to miss!”

Here is one of those stories as told by a Florida attorney by the name of Jonathan Pollard. He is the principal of his own law practice, Pollard LLC in Fort Lauderdale, and his experience is one that should send chills through every recruiter and hiring manager who has ever had a similar thing happen to them.

An interview to remember

Here is Pollard’s experience, taken from his blog on LinkedIn. See if it sounds like something you’ve been through too:

Guy with a Harvard MBA applied to be our operations director. We had a meeting set for noon on Thursday. At 10:30 he emails and says he MIGHT be 10 to 15 minutes late. Around 12:15, my office reaches out to him. No response.

He rolls into the office at 1 pm. The receptionist buzzes me. I’ve got a 1 pm on one of my biggest cases. I go out to the lobby, because I just have to meet this dude. I introduce myself and say, “So it’s 1 pm. What happened?” His response: “I was in a meeting in Miami and couldn’t get out of it.

I’m a bit confused, so I ask what he means. He says, with a tremendous air of self-importance, “Yeah, I was meeting with a company that wants me to be their CEO, run the whole company.”

I’m perfectly calm. I explain that I have a 1 pm on a big case. And I say something like, “You know, you could have just emailed or called if you were going to be an hour late.” The guy gets angry and says, “I’m not going to have you lecture me. I’m here. So either you want to meet or not.”

No, I don’t.

The dude was somewhat shocked. He stood there speechless for a couple seconds. I guess he’s used to people fawning all over him because of his Harvard MBA. No matter how elite someone’s credentials or skill-set, that kind of person is a cancer in any business.”

“An idiot with a Harvard MBA is still an idiot”

Wonder if stories like this resonate with people? Well, Attorney Pollard’s blog post generated 20,609 likes and 1,456 comments — all over the Memorial Day weekend!

The comments from readers were as almost as interesting as the story. Here are a few to give you a sense of how others reacted to this guy:

  • “Best job interview ever!!! Good for you in making a clear, direct and instant decision on what values, behavior and management practices it would take to fit in and succeed on your team, regardless of pedigree, and based on actual situational action.”
  • “If you are smart, remember to be humble; if you are humble, remember to be smart; if you are neither humble or smart? Good luck, you are pretty much a roadblock for success!!”
  • An idiot with a Harvard MBA is still an idiot — he just happens to be potentially a more dangerous idiot.”

Anyone who has done much recruiting or hiring at all probably has a story of a “can’t miss” candidate that turned south abruptly and unexpectedly, and in the end, they were glad that it did. That’s because there is probably nothing worse than a top notch “can’t miss” candidate that everybody drools over that somehow takes a wrong turn.

5 hiring takeaways to remember

There are five (5) brief insights you should take away from this cautionary tale:

  1. Stories like this are a reminder of why you put so much into interviewing and examining candidates, because sometimes the ones that have the most incredible resumes and credentials are a surprise when you actually meet them in person.
  2. The interview stage is where you find out whether the candidate has the right values, behavior, and outlook that would fit with your organization’s culture. This is something that is hard to get off a resume.
  3.  You should expect to see people at their very best when you meet them in person. It should tell you something if you don’t, because that’s probably as good as it is going to get with them.
  4. People with a large dose of attitude (aka prima donnas) are hard for co-workers to stomach — even when they are “A” players and immensely talented. Hire them at your own risk.
  5. Here’s the big question you want the interview to answer: Is this person a good fit for this job and this organization?

A few years ago, a savvy CEO that I worked for told me that a great many companies don’t really know what they’re looking for when they hire, so they aren’t in a position to recognize someone who might be perfect even if they’re standing right in front of them.

I’ve thought about that wisdom a lot over the years, and I can’t tell you how many times I have found it to be true.

Maybe Attorney Jonathan Pollard didn’t know exactly what he was looking for in an operations director, but one thing is clear — he knew what he DIDN’T want, and that was someone with a huge attitude who was rude, insensitive, and incredibly impressed with themselves.

He couldn’t have known that until he met this guy. There’s a lesson there that we should all keep in mind.

20 Years in Recruiting: I’m Amazed Where We Are — and Where We’re Going

About 20 years ago, I fell into this business wide-eyed, filled with wonderment, and not sure what the new day was going to produce.

I was young, but not too naïve. Yes, I did have a great deal to learn and I’m still learning even now by attending conferences, reading posts from other recruiters, etc. I’m amazed by all the different ways we find people.

As recruiters we are, first and foremost, in the people business. There is no Artificial Intelligence, at least not now, that can rightly predict what a person is going to do 100 percent of the time, and neither can anyone else. Well, except for an FBI profiler. They are scary good with that and I thank God that they are.

Tools are like nothing else, and when put them in the right hands with the proper training they can be very, very, useful. However, unless you are using them they just sit there in your tray hoping they get picked to play (I feel there is a Pixar movie somewhere in all this). There is a symbiotic relationship between you and an app, and by using a tool, something comes from it. Hopefully, it is something useful.

I am all too familiar with the constant conversation that recruiting is dead and that we will be replaced by machines. I shake my head every time I hear that. After 20 years in this business, I’m still going strong, people still hire me, and all the things I have seen from an inventive perspective have made many lives a little bit easier.

My generation has witnessed some of the greatest innovations that any generation has ever seen, and as I sit here writing on a tablet less than one inch thick (having learned to type on a Remington Brand typewriter) I’m still amazed at where we are and where we’re going.

Yes, we used to do things a little differently

So, for the less ancient of you out there reading this, let me show you some of the things we did not have 20 years ago OR that were pretty new back then. We were still placing people but NOT with the tools we have now. For instance:

  • Job board postings — Well, we did have Monster and eventually Dice, but the likes of Indeed, CareerBuilder, craigslist, and others were still to come, and job boards in general were more of a luxury for us and just as expensive back then as they are now.
  • Believe it or not, we actually posted job ads in newspapers — You may have seen newspapers at the grocery store, and most people use them for bird cages, packing paper, and crossword puzzles now.
  • We used fax machines — Many companies didn’t trust them back then, and since the signature on a faxed document was a facsimile, it was not considered legally binding. So, the only thing they were good for was sending and receiving resumes.
  • People would snail mail resumes to companies or fax them to us — We had the worst facsimile paper that would always be overtly glossy and roll up since, well, it came from a roll of paper that would always roll up and you could never write on it. It used to drive me freaking batty!
  • We had email but MS Hotmail was the only free email service — You paid for the others unless you had an office account with Outlook, or subscribed to AOL (Remember YOU GOT MAIL! ?) Also, American Express did not trust receiving emails because they might get a virus. And, most people couldn’t figure out how to open an attachment (like my company’s biggest client at the time).
  • Speaking of viruses, does anyone over the age of 35 remember the “I love you” virus? — Yeah, we all thought that was a real hoot until we realized all of our information was no longer in our system as it was wiped out from clicking on that little icon. Maybe the AMEX staff was not really that stupid after all.
  • Google was just getting started — All of those fantastic Chrome extensions that you may or may not use today were not around back then. I think I hear gasping when you read this one. In fact, Google started out as a search engine that ran on IE until they came up with Chrome a little later.
  • There was no Facebook — We actually, you know, met up somewhere and talked to one another — in person! That’s a shocker to so many people now.
  • I used to receive resumes via the actual U.S. mail carrier — They had a stamp, return address, and everything.
  • We walked to work uphill, in the snow, and braved 40 mile per hour winds both ways getting to work — Sorry, I had to throw something snarky in there — you know me!
  • Headsets were not wireless and had an annoying cord that always seemed to rip your ears off — This happened if you turned your head too fast one way or the other.
  • We had paper everywhere and actually wrote things down with a pen — Yes, we handed written notes to managers instead of emailing them.
  • LinkedIn had just started and none of us knew how to actually use it for recruiting — Back then, you just got excited someone wanted to connect with you online, well, with a few small exceptions (Yes, I’m looking at you Stacy Donovan  Zapar).
  • Facebook did not exist at all — It started in 2004, so before that we just called each other! In fact, texting on a cell phone was not even a thing. It was, in short, a pain in the ass and no one knew you could communicate that way.
  • There were no smartphones — There were dumb phones that worked and we talked on them and paid a boatload of money to use them. OK, that has remained constant I guess.
  • We talked a great deal on the phone — We did not email questions; we asked people questions because there was a need to get a feel for how someone explained things.
  • We took copious amounts of notes — We kept the notes in the computer system so that we could track where we were with the candidate. We call this an ATS now. You’re welcome.

Today’s struggle may all be in your head

There is a LOT more I am sure I’m missing here, and I would love for some of the other kids that have been in this business to add things to the comments that I may have passed by.

So, if you are new to recruiting please realize that if you think the struggle today is real it really is not. It’s all in your head and I’m sure there is an app that can fix it for you. In fact, send me your fax number and I can jot down some notes and send it over to you.

You’re welcome. #zellerout

ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Derek Zeller draws from over 16 years in the recruiting industry. The last 11 years he has been involved with federal government recruiting specializing within the cleared Intel space under OFCCP compliance. He currently serves as a Technical Recruiting Lead at Comscore.

The Five: Must See Sessions at Globoforce WorkHuman 2017

Globoforce WorkHuman 2017

What do employee recognition programs have to do with recruiting? More than you think. When sourcing and recruiting talent, you aren’t just looking for a body to fill a role; you are looking for candidates that will like working for the company you are recruiting for. Candidates are looking to work at a company that will invest in their employees. As a recruiter, you cannot control what a company invests in its employees. A company’s reputation is dependent on how current employees feel at work.

This week we are attending #WorkHuman – an HR conference pioneered by Globoforce.  We are here to examine how much employee recognition effects the ability to recruit top talent. We are also excited about the guest keynote speakers. Here are the five sessions we are most excited about.

1. The Talent Ecosystem: How to Find, Develop, and Retain Your Workforce

Speaker: Susan Hanold

Human Capital Management platforms are dramatically changing the landscape of HR departments. They provide intelligent ways to streamline processes and knock out the many manual and redundant tasks that bog down HR. Though technology is rapidly transforming the way we work, it isn’t the only factor to consider when building teams for tomorrow. This presentation will illuminate the crucial trends shaping today’s working environments.

We will learn about:

  • What are forward-thinking organizations planning as they look ahead to 2020 and beyond?
  • Trends in performance management and the job hopper’s market
  • Research from the ADP Research Institute and Innovation Lab and insights from ADP’s approximately 600,000 clients on the Talent Ecosystem

Dr. Susan Hanold serves as vice president for Strategic Advisory Services at ADP. She is responsible for working with clients to provide strategy, consultation and practical talent management solutions to help drive organizational change. Her experience has cut across industries spanning from large, multi-nationals to national organizations pursuing global growth. ADP’s Strategic Advisory Services is a team of experts who help clients develop and execute highly effective Human Capital Management (HCM).  Their focus strategies are in the areas of compliance, data analytics, decision support and analytics, service delivery, workforce, talent management, and communications. Dr. Hanold has more than 20 years of results-based leadership experience as an executive coach and organization development expert.  She continues to work with corporations to help them develop their talent strategy.

WorkHuman2. Using Data to Find Your Hidden Talent Pool

Speaker: Marcy Ricci

With the right recognition solution in place, you could be sitting on a treasure trove of business intelligence. Learn how to move beyond simple reporting on budgets. Reach metrics of powerful and graphical insights that offer a real-time view of your program and people in action. What’s more, you can predict flight risks, track rising stars, and keep tabs on team engagement across departments.

Marcy is a solutions consultant for Globoforce, where she currently serves as a recognition solution expert within the company’s North American sales team. Along with conceptualizing, communicating and demonstrating how Globoforce’s products and services help drive a company’s business performance to sales prospects, Ricci is also an advisor between the company’s sales, product, marketing, strategy and consulting, and customer success teams.

3. Raising the Bar: Creating a Great Place to Work For All

Speaker: Chinwe Onyeagoro

Did you know that there is a group of companies that has outperformed the market every year for the last twenty years, and the common denominator of these organizations is the quality of the relationships between employees and their leaders? Given the pace of change in business, companies need to create an environment in which everyone, no matter who they are or what they do for the organization, is fully unlocked to contribute their best. Anything less represents untapped human potential. Leveraging more than 20 years of research and feedback from 100 million employees and tens of thousands of organizations across 57 countries, Chinwe Onyeagoro – president and chief strategy officer of Great Place to Work, and expert on leadership and workplace culture – shares actionable, contrarian insights that will compel you to take another look at your employee value proposition, employee engagement goals, and leadership development approach.

Onyeagoro serves as president & chief strategy officer of Great Place to Work®. She oversees the U.S. business, including the certification, employee survey, and consulting businesses. She works with executives in successfully executing business strategy through developing high-trust, high-performance cultures. Her executive advisory work with Great Place to Work® includes multi-billion dollar technology companies. She is leading culture management and culture integration work with executives at the largest telecommunications company, the largest bio-pharma company, and the fastest growing SaaS companies in the world.

WorkHuman4. The Emerging Work World In The Participation Age

Speaker: Chuck Blakeman

Companies of every size are leaving behind the outdated management practices of the industrial age to grow exponentially faster, with fewer employees. They’re doing it with a “Participation Age” culture where people require very little management, employee turnover is lower, and employees become committed stakeholders.

Chuck Blakeman will discuss:

  • Why the management practices we inherited from the factory system are destructive
  • Why the emerging work world will be built around the Participation Age
  • Why we must replace employees with stakeholders, and managers with Leaders
  • Why Participation Age leadership creates faster growth, higher profits, and more longevity
  • How to become a Participation Age Company

Chuck Blakeman is a successful entrepreneur, best-selling business author and world-renowned business advisor who built ten businesses in seven industries on four continents, and now uses his experience to advise others. His company, Crankset Group, provides outcome-based mentoring and peer advisory for business leaders worldwide. Chuck sold one of his businesses to the largest consumer fulfillment company in America and led three other $10-$100 million companies. He presently leads the Crankset Group and a for-profit business based in Africa, focused on developing local economies to solve poverty. Chuck is a results leader with decades of experience leading companies in marketing, import/export, fulfillment, call centers, website development, printing and direct mail processing.

5.  A Conversation with Michelle Obama

This one is unbelievable. Yes, Former First Lady Michelle Obama will be at WorkHuman. “Michelle Obama has inspired us in every sense of the word,” said Eric Mosley, CEO of Globoforce. “As First Lady, she was wholeheartedly dedicated to the human cause – striving to uplift others, improve the quality of life for people around the world, and giving a voice to the people who often go unheard. She has long recognized the importance of diversity of ideas and people, and the fundamental need for people to feel valued and appreciated. We are honored to host such a strong leader–Michelle Obama’s energy and passion will help propel the WorkHuman movement and inspire top senior HR leaders in the world to create more human workplaces where employees feel a sense of belonging and can be their most authentic selves.”

Can You Hire Based on a 5 Minute Interview?

What would you ask someone if you had only five (5) minutes to interview them?

It’s an intriguing question because it adds an element to interviewing that you normally don’t see, especially if you are interviewing a candidate for a job. Of course, it also begs the question, “who only has five minutes to interview someone for a job?

If anything, hiring trends are going the other way, with job candidates subjected to a number of rounds of interviews with multiple interviewers. In fact, my friend and master recruiter Tim Sackett was WAY ahead of the trend when he blogged about the multiple rounds of interviews phenomena way back in 2013.

Keeping job interviews from getting abusive

Tim wrote:

I had a client recently that was undecided about a candidate after the 4th round interview. They were thinking that maybe a fifth round would make the difference. I told them that it wouldn’t. In fact, it was a mistake to allow them to get to four.

Do you know what the fourth round interview says about your (hiring) process?

It says that your process is broken. No one needs four rounds of interviews to decide if a candidate is the right candidate for your organization. A fifth round, or any number higher, is just adding insult to injury.”

Tim was right then and he’s even more right today given how many candidates are subjected to multiple rounds of mind-numbing interviews that don’t seem to get them any closer to being hired. In my book, it shouldn’t take more than three rounds to figure out if someone is right for a job. Any more than that is candidate abuse — especially if you don’t end up hiring them.

That’s why I was intrigued when I saw this question in a recent New York Times Corner Office column that asked Mike O’Neill, the chief executive of music rights company BMI, “If you only had five minutes to interview someone, what would you ask them?”

This question resonated with me not only because I recently had a futile, multiple rounds of interviews that could have gotten us to the same conclusion after a single discussion, but also because it’s premise is tantalizing provocative.

Can you find out all you need in 5 minutes?

What it comes down to it this: Is it possible to craft a question (or two) so well that you can find out all you need to know to make a decision about hiring the person in only five (5) minutes?

Here’s what Mike O’Neill told The New York Times he would ask if he only had five minutes to spare:

Tell me about the current environment you’re in or the current position you hold. What don’t you like about the culture of the place or the person you’re working with? Why are you looking to leave?

I love those questions, because they allow you to see whether the person is leaving for money, or because of the culture, or for a new opportunity. What are they looking for in their lives that they’re not getting in their current environment?

And do I have something that I could offer them that might fit that role? It will allow me to see that immediately.

There are right and wrong flavors of answers. And they might have the absolute correct answer, but I might not have the solution for them. So I know even if I offer them a job, it’s not going to satisfy what they need.”

Right and wrong flavors of answers

I like what O’Neill said in that last part — “there are right and wrong flavors of answers” — because that speaks to the skill of the interviewer, especially a recruiter who may be screening the candidate for the hiring manager. Yes, for the most part, there are no right and wrong answers, but there may be answers that lean one way or the other depending on how the candidate responds to the interviewer.

The art of it all is being able to get candidates to give you the right flavor of an answer to make a smart decision about whether you should move ahead on them — or not.

In my experience, multiple interviews are usually a good thing because each interviewer generally gets something out of the candidate that the others didn’t. But, I also agree with Tim Sackett that more than three rounds of interviews are non-productive and border on abuse.

But, I also believe that a great interviewer CAN get all they need out of a candidate in five minutes if they’re smart and skilled at the art of the interview. In fact, a number of my very best hires over the years were people who I was able to figure out in the first five minutes I was talking to them.

Ever hired someone on the basis of a very brief interview? Have you had good/bad experiences with multiple rounds of people grilling candidates? I’d love to hear if you have some insights.

A Day in the Life: RPO Edition

There are all types of roles in the recruiting industry.  We asked top peeps in the industry to give us a sense of what it is they do on a daily basis. What’s the first thing they do in the morning? Do they have an office, or do they sit with the team? What do they eat for lunch? Here is, a day in the life for Dan Louks.

It’s a Beautiful Morning

4:50 a.m. I’m awake. This isn’t by choice, rather a byproduct of a raging case of anxiety that I’ve dealt with for the past eight years or so. I quietly creep to the foyer, bypass the security alarm as to not scare the living hell out of my wife, daughter, and two cats. Then I’m off to our attached garage to fall down a YouTube or Twitter rabbit hole until it’s time to get dressed.

RPO Life

 

6:30 a.m. I’m headed out the door, dreading the autobahn-esque highway commute ahead of me where it’s every man, woman, and child for themselves. Bonus: The temperature outside is comparable to that of a blast chiller, because… Ohio. Don’t worry; it’s supposed to be 62° tomorrow. Next week it’s back into the teens. I’m sure pneumonia sounds worse than it actually is…

6:50 a.m. I’m first to arrive, as per usual. Time to open up shop. I power on my laptop & desk fan, and then I head to the break room to brew the oh-so-important first pot of coffee that allows the entire office to function for the first ninety minutes or so of the day. While that’s percolating, I run out to the arctic tundra that is the parking lot to suck down a quick cigarette before peering at my inbox and calendar, as I’m not eager to learn what mystery box of stress awaits me.

6:58 a.m. Coffee in hand, it’s time to dive in. “All folders are up to date. Connected to: Microsoft Exchange”.

RPO Life

 

Oh shit, that’s right. I have to get those  “Maintenance Manager” resumes over to Alexis this morning, for that req she’s had open since the Reagan administration. She said the call with her hiring manager is at 11:30, so that should be plenty of time.

*Reluctantly open my calendar, peering with one sleep-encrusted eye open*

Damn. I totally forgot about my 9:00 a.m. meeting with the boss to update him on that six-week pipelining project I’m in the middle of, which I am so not prepared to do. I better give myself about an hour to 1) pull the new results from my various saved searches, download them all, 2) rename them, so I’m not sending over thirty variations of “updated_res2017_proofreed.pdf” to the internal Recruiter I’m working with on the client side, and 3) a couple of minutes to smash my brains back into my skull and come up with something semi-intelligent that loosely resembles an update to pass along.

Holy run-on sentence, Batman.

Alright, so that gives me about an hour to do a couple of thorough searches for Alexis before I have to tend to the pipelining shenanigans.

7:00 a.m. *Outlook pop-up* “Reminder: Wrap-up Compensation Report Before call with Client @ 10″ …

RPO Life

 

Blerg. Alright, maybe things with the boss will wrap up in less than thirty minutes, which should give me enough time to pull the numbers for the wage analysis before the 10:00 call. Well… it looks like I know what I’m doing this morning.

I start a fresh tab in Chrome, pop my Bluetooth earbuds in, pull up the Spotify app on my phone, and crank it up to eleven.

*Shuffle play “Your Top Songs 2016”: Now Playing “Do the Evolution” by Pearl Jam*

Let’s Get This Party Started

7:52 a.m. Chugging along on LinkedIn Recruiter, doing a decent amount of damage on the Maintenance Manager scavenger hunt. It’s a shame the hiring manager on the other end of this equation won’t waiver from his demand that the only candidates he’ll consider are ones who’ve performed maintenance work exclusively in the glass manufacturing industry. Seeing as how there’s an 800+ employee plastics packaging plant eight miles away who pays their maintenance workers $3.00 less per hour, who essentially maintain the same type of molding machinery that’s used in the glass factory, it seems like something you should be willing to bend on. I digress. I’ve got some names, and I’m in decent shape despite the hiring manager tomfoolery.

*Up walks Anonymous Account Manager, unexpected and unannounced as always*

RPO Life

 

“Morning, Dan! Hey real quick, I know you’re busy, and you’ve got a ton going on, but is there any way that you can look into those Flight Nursing associations you and I were chatting about a couple of days ago? We still have those three open positions in Nebraska, and we’re not getting any applications, so we could really use anything you come across. If you can grab a committee directory really quick or some sort of contact list, that would be awesome. I don’t need it this morning or anything, but maybe if you could find something by my call with ‘Client Blah Blah Blah’ at 2:00?”

*Uttered through clenched yet smiling teeth*

“Sure! I’ve got a couple of things going on, but I can work on that for you a little later!”

Lunch is dumb anyway. I’ll just grab a couple of those Laffy Taffys from the snack jar in the conference room. I’m sure the growling in my stomach will gradually drop to a dull whisper after that.

 

10:32 a.m. Everything went smoothly with the boss, and the 10:00 call went fine with the client. Thankfully, the wage analysis info I pulled perfectly aligned with what they were expecting, so it’s reassuring to be sporadically reminded that I’m not completely full of shit and actually know a thing or two. A little under an hour until Alexis’ call, so I better bust some ass in hopes I can find her some decent candidates before her hiring manager shows up to break her kneecaps.

*Shuffle play “The Essential Stevie Ray Vaughan”: Now Playing “Pride and Joy”*

11:37 a.m. It looks as if the tweaks I made to my search strings paid off, as I was able to pass along four rock solid resumes that she can follow up on and brag about on her call. I’m sure that once she gets them pre-screened and scheduled for a face to face interview, she’ll suddenly have a hard time getting the hiring manager’s availability. Subsequently, the candidate then loses interest, and we get to do this all over again. Job security, I suppose.

 

It’s time to find out whatever I can on Flight Nurses in Nebraska. I’m sure there’s two on every corner, much like a Walgreens or Rite-Aid. I mean hell, the first two things I think of when I hear Nebraska is booming metropolises and niche healthcare workers. Now that I let off some sarcasm, I’m feeling slightly more optimistic about my assignment.

Afternoon Delight

2:42 p.m. I found out shortly before the 2:00 call that it was probably “easiest” for me to jump on myself and riff on what I was able to come up with. Though it really wasn’t a big deal, my anxiety felt otherwise about it, so I’m headed outside for another frostbitten smoke break.

*Shuffle play “90’s Hip-Hop Playlist”: Now Playing “It Takes Two” by Rob Base & DJ EZ Rock*

2:56 p.m. Back at my desk after the 19th trip to the men’s room to rid myself of a few more fluid ounces of the liter o’ coffee I’ve consumed today. It looks like I’ve got a little over an hour to tend to a handful of housecleaning items, that will only scratch the surface of what’s needed. Should I spend some time to gather intel on the three recruitment text messaging services I’ve been looking at for the RPO group that I started on a month ago? Do I dig deeper into that System Director of Development search that I’ve got a week left on? Perhaps I can try to catch the boss and see if he’s had a chance to look over that information I sent him about the new Facebook Jobs feature. Eh, his door’s closed which means he’s on conference call #42 of the day. Let’s wrap up that texting research and be done with it so it’s off of my plate.

3:39 p.m. One of the company’s own partners (who I might add is an amazingly handsome and incredibly talented young man. Did I mention young?) approaches my desk with excitement on his face and a pep in his step. This means I’m about to learn about the next “project” that I’m going to be working on. I grab my notebook, turn to a fresh page and follow him into his office to get the details.

 

Last Dance

4:03 p.m. Power down the laptop & desk fan. I’m getting the hell out of here. Tonight’s the wife’s workout class at the Y, which means I’m on solo daddy duty until that’s over and done with. Off to the in-laws to pick up the tiny beautiful weirdo that is my daughter, so I can hang out with someone with my maturity level (she’s 4). I can just forget about the mayhem that just ensued and put it out of mind. Until it nudges me out of bed tomorrow morning, and I get to do it all over again.

But you know what? I love what I do, and I wouldn’t change a thing. It takes a special kind of crazy to be a Sourcer, and I’d like to think I’ve got plenty of crazy to go around.

 

About our Author:

Dan Louks has been working in RPO for about three years now, having spent time as both a Recruiter and a Sourcer. In a previous life, he has worked primarily in radio broadcasting and retail sales. Married with a four-year-old daughter, he is either hanging out with them or playing retro video games in my free time. Connect with him on  LinkedIn or connect with him on Twitter.

Want to Recruit Great People? It Helps If You’re a Great Place to Work

Here’s a recruiting lesson to keep in mind: great workplaces are about great workplace cultures — and when you have a great culture, people will break down your door to come work for you.

I’m at the Great Place to Work conference in Chicago this week, and it’s not the first time I’ve attended and heard from some of the organizations who make the annual Best Companies to Work For list give their insights into what it takes to be a great place to work.

Each one has their own little twist on that, of course, but in the end, it all comes down to one thing: Great workplaces are the product of great cultures.

Just a quick scan of the 2017 list — it’s published in Fortune magazine each year — reads like a Who’s Who of great companies from No. 1 ranked Google down to Allianz Life Insurance Company of North America at No. 100.

Culture is the key to a great place to work

The criteria for the list is pretty straightforward:

To identify the 100 Best Companies to Work For, each year Fortune partners with Great Place to Work to conduct the most extensive employee survey in corporate America. The ranking is based on feedback from more than 232,000 employees at Great Place to Work–Certified companies with more than 1,000 employees.

Winning a spot on this list indicates the company has distinguished itself from peers by creating a great place to work for employees – measured and ranked through our analysis of the results of our Trust Index survey and Culture Audit questionnaire.

Through the Trust Index, employees anonymously assess their workplace, including the honesty and quality of communication by managers, degree of support for employees’ personal and professional lives, and the authenticity of relationships with colleagues. Results from the survey are highly reliable, having a 95 percent confidence level and a margin of error of 5 percent or less. Companies’ results on the Trust Index survey are compared to peer organizations of like size and complexity.”

Of course, nothing in the criteria for the Best Companies to Work For List says anything about culture, but if you listen to executives from some of the companies here at the conference, they’ll say that’s the key to everything.

Great cultures attract great talent

John Chambers of Cisco — No. 67 on this year’s list  — said that “culture is the foundation” of his company’s success and is the one sustaining element that has driven Cisco over the last 20 years that they have been named a Best Company to Work For. Most of the other executives who spoke on Day 1 here in Chicago — from companies as diverse as Genentic, PwC, At&T — had their own spin on this, too.

But one thing Chambers said resonated with me, as it should resonate with you if you’re in the business of recruiting, hiring, and managing talent:

Access to great talent is a big differentiator in business … (and) great companies will grow and maintain talent like no one else.”

This is the key to why culture is such a huge focus for organizations that are a Great Place to Work. It’s because if you can get the culture right, everything else flows from that, including your ability to recruit and hold on to great talent. And the ability to assemble great talent is the key to sustaining a great business.

A number of executives mentioned how their employee retention rates were much better than their competitors because of their culture and the fact that they were a Great Place to Work. Not only does that make it easier to get great talent to come to you, it also makes it easier to hold on to that talent when you get them in the front door.

Yes, great talent wants to work with other great talent in an environment that appreciates the great talents that the bring to the table.

What kind of culture are you building?

It’s also the difference between a company like Cisco, that has been on the 100 Best Companies to Work For list for 20 years, and a hot young company like Uber that, despite all of its success, seems to be building a dysfunctional culture that is driving people away.

As I wrote recently when digging into Uber’s culture:

I don’t know if Uber ever truly planned for the dysfunctional culture they have today, but that’s how it goes when it comes to company culture. You usually get the one you deserve.

Culture flows from the organization’s core values, and if the core values espouse the notion that accepted, long-standing rules don’t apply and that you can do whatever you want, well, you’re going to get a workplace culture where everybody thinks the normal rules don’t apply, too.”

In my book, culture is the key to everything, and everything flows from a great culture. Yes, everybody talks about the importance of employee engagement, but in my book, great engagement flows out of your culture. If you build the culture right, great engagement will follow.

That’s my big takeaway from Day 1 of the Great Place to Work Conference here in Chicago, although honestly, I knew that before I got here. It just helps hearing it from so many great companies who have worked so hard to

A Word to the Wise: Leaders and Managers Need to Be Good Recruiters, Too

So, you finally got that fancy management title you’ve been waiting for. Congratulations!

But now what? You think you’re ready? It’s not that simple, my friends!

You can have all the leadership training that exists under your belt or even decades of leadership experience, but in today’s world that just is not enough anymore.

So, why not?

Let’s think about this together: What is the first part of the employee life cycle? It’s recruiting. That’s right. It is about sifting through a sea of potential candidates. And, guess what? That sea is humongous!

Why? That’s because it is no longer just full of people who are looking for a job. Some of your best candidates (and hires) are going to be people who already have a job and are not looking to make a switch.

You might still be in denial. Many people are still in denial. It’s time to come back to reality, though.

Every leader must also be a recruiter

With so many recruiting tools and social media tools available, there’s no reason why every leader in an organization can’t also wear the hat of a recruiter. Plus, before you can successfully lead a team of people, you really have to know how to successfully get those people.

If you hire the right people up front, all of those parts of leadership we hate to do becomes a lot easier, or dare I say it, unnecessary — things like conflict management, corrective action and terminations., and all sorts of other difficult conversations.

So, why are you making it so difficult for yourself?

This is not to say that recruiters are no longer needed, but as a leader, you know your employees, your departments, and your organizational needs better than anyone. For example, if you invest some time to understand how to source and recruit on social media platforms such as LinkedIn and Twitter, you could increase your pool of strong candidates who may have not even even known about your organization — or your job posting.

Even at the simplest level, you should be sharing your job posting with your network. For the recruiter to just post a job on LinkedIn, for example, he or she is only reaching the audience who uses the job feature, or the people in his or her network who most likely are not looking for the kind of position you’re hiring for. However, your network probably has other people in your industry or line of work who may actually be looking to make a move.

Managing and recruiting go hand in hand

But don’t just do the simple things though. After you get comfortable with posting and sharing on social media, you have to quickly begin engaging potential candidates.

Make sure to respond to people who apply, and, post meaningful questions. For example, start a conversation on social media that gets to what people are looking for in an organizational culture, a leader, or a team. This could go viral, or at least locally-viral, and attract the attention of even more potential candidates to your company.

So, what are you waiting for?

It’s time to become a more efficient and effective leader by learning to recruit the best of the best. Managing just isn’t much fun without strong recruitment first!

About our author: Lotus Yon is an HR and leadership fanatic who geeks out when talking about the future of the workplace. She is an experienced HR leader, mostly in the health care industry, and writes on her OD Advocate blog. She has also been featured on Ragan Communications, HealthcareSource, Allen Communication and YouTern. Lotus is passionate about disrupting the industry and helping HR professionals think differently about their work and its impact on the greater good of their organizations.

Find Contact Information with Skipease

Ever find yourself having to go from site to site to find contact information for potential candidates? Skipease can help alleviate your pain. Skipease is a free people search and public records directory where you can search for and find contact information and public records on people by name, location, address or phone number. Go to one place to find a collection of the best people and public record searches including:

Consequently, I was shocked to see what some of the sites were able to find about me. See what it can find about you by going to Skipease.com.

 

Wath me us Skipease

 

Find COntact InformationAbout our Author:

Dean Da Costa is best known for his work in the highly specialized secured clearance and mobile arenas, where he has been a top performing recruiter and sourcer.  Dean’s keen insight and creation of innovative tools and processes for enhancing and changing staffing has established Dean as one of the top authorities in sourcing and recruiting.

Connect with Dean at LinkedIn or follow @DeanDaCosta on Twitter.

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly of the Candidate Experience

Want to know what is critically important for every recruiter and hiring manager? It’s remembering what it’s like to be on the other side of the table.

Yes, everyone who recruits or hires should have to be a job candidate sometime.

The candidate experience has been on my mind because I have been on the market for the last six months experiencing the good, the bad, and the ugly (well, mainly the bad and ugly) of looking for a new job.

  • The good is that I had some really great jobs pop up that I was all but offered.
  • The bad is that the best jobs I thought I had locked down, without warning, fell off the face of the Earth.
  • The ugly part? It’s those very people who seemed to want me to work for them one day suddenly went incommunicado and treated me as if I had ebola. I couldn’t get them to respond to save my life.

Three jobs, three bad experiences

The details are instructive, especially if you’re hiring people:

  • Job No. 1 was with a guy in Boston I met through a close member of his family I had worked with. He had a media wing to his company that I could help get back on track. After a year of talking, a half dozen written proposals, and one trip to Boston, he told me at Thanksgiving he was “ready to take a swing at this.” It sounded good, and we agreed I would start in mid-January after I returned from a long-scheduled trip. End result: I never heard from the guy again, and I never heard from the close family member I had worked with either. Both of them refused to respond at all, even to tell me that the deal was off. To this day, I don’t know what the hell happened.
  • Job No. 2 was a gig with a big consulting firm that wanted me to write a column for their new magazine. I talked with the editor in November, we agreed on the pay rate, and, that I would probably get started in February. I then spent a month filling out paperwork and dealing with a nice person in the company’s HR department. End result: I never heard from the editor again despite my many attempts to reach her. I did, however, hear from my HR contact in the company recently who asked if I could send over an updated auto insurance card for my file. I told her what had happened and she said she would check on it, but that’s as far as it went. I still don’t know what went wrong.
  • Job No. 3 came from an ad I saw seeking an Editor for a “major West Coast business publication.” Although it was terribly vague, I had once been the successful Editor of a major West Coast business publication, so I applied. Two weeks later, the publisher called. Turns out the publication is not only very near me but is part of the company that owns the business publication I used to edit. They not only know me well but tried to hire me back one time. Sounds like the perfect situation, no? I thought so, and after the publisher’s call, I had three days of conversations about the position, including one in the office. But then, the talking stopped as suddenly as it started. End result: A week later, I texted the publisher to ask where things stood. His response? “We are far down the road with another candidate, but nothing final yet.” And, that’s the last I heard from him. Of course, they hired an Editor — someone who, as far as I can tell, has never, ever been a top Editor or managed a staff — but they never told me of their decision despite assurances they would “let me know.” Oh well, so much for professional courtesy. C’est la vie.

Millennials seem to be treated worst of all

So, what do all these situations have in common? That’s easy — they’re all prime examples of a terribly bad and indifferent candidate experience.

When I tell people about my job hunting woes, the response from the Millennials is the most telling of all. They generally say something along the lines of, “Wow. I thought it was only the younger people who got treated like that.”

Clearly, the stories about how poorly companies treat job candidates are alive and well. Sadly, they seem to resonate most with the largest part of our workforce.

My biggest gripe is that these companies couldn’t be honest and tell me they didn’t want to hire me after making me think they did. They simply couldn’t say, “sorry, this isn’t going to work out.” It also reinforces something I have always told my managers — the worst answer in life isn’t no; the worst answer in life is no answer at all and to be left spinning your wheels.

A great many companies seem to have a problem communicating with candidates, and the 2016 Talent Board North American Candidate Experience Awards Research Report  makes this clear:

In 2016, 47 percent of candidates were still waiting to hear back from employers more than two months after they applied. Plus, only 20 percent of candidates received an email from a recruiter or hiring manager notifying them they were not being considered, and only 8 percent received a phone call from a recruiter or hiring manager notifying them they were not being considered.”

4 ways to improve the Candidate Experience

I know that the volume of candidates most recruiters deal with makes it hard to respond, but in my case, these were not situations where I was one out of a thousand resumes that applied to their ad. I was a top candidate and they STILL couldn’t extend me the courtesy of an honest reply.

My friend Kevin Grossman, who works for the Talent Board and understands the need for a good Candidate Experience as well as anyone, makes these recommendations for companies trying to get better at this:

Major changes take time and resources, but what talent acquisition teams could do now to improve candidate communication throughout any part of the recruiting cycle is to do a combination of these four (4) simple things regularly:

  • Thank the candidates for their time – always;
  • Follow up with recommendations on what can be improved or what missed the mark;
  • End with positive comments about the situation, no matter what;
  • Not only give positive feedback but ask for it as well.

These are simple things, yet a great many organizations can’t even get them right.

Here’s why this is important: How you treat people in situations like this says a lot about your organization’s values. Any company can treat top candidates well (although that not always a given, as I found out), but how they act toward the great nameless, faceless mass of people who apply to them really speaks volumes about how they treat not only those who actually do get hired, but how they probably treat their customers too.

It’s a version of the Golden Rule — treat your job candidates as YOU want to be treated. If you truly care about the Candidate Experience, this shouldn’t be so hard for recruiters and talent managers to understand.

The Five: Movies All Recruiters Must Watch

These are the five movies all recruiters must watch.If you look for movies with “Recruit” or “Human Resources” in the title, they are almost always about criminals or police work. And while, that is ok none of them made this list. For recruiters, we have to get a little creative about where to look for inspiration. Well we found them.  Take a look at the list below. Any self-respecting recruiter owes it to his or herself to watch all of these at least once. Here are the five movies all recruiters must watch.

Moneyball (2011)

Oakland A’s General Manager Billy Beane has his back against the wall to assemble a winning baseball team with the lowest salary constraint in baseball. He hires a young Ivy League grad to scientifically analyze data based on Bill James’ statistic approach so that Beane can select undervalued players based on their on base percentages.

You may think that the lesson recruiters will learn by watching this movie is about ingenuity and out of the box thinking. And, it does illustrate the importance of creative thinking and why you should implement new processes to drive change and innovative solutions. But the scene below may be the most important lesson to learn, “Adapt or Die.” AKA accept machine learning and artificial intelligence technologies. They are here and yes they will replace certain tasks once done by a person. But this is a good thing. We are evolving.

You can also read the book Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game by Michael Lewis.

 

The Internship (2013)

After old-school salesmen Billy and Nick find themselves downsized, Billy decides that, despite their complete lack of technological savvy, they should work for Google. The friends somehow manage to finagle internships at the Internet giant and promptly head out to Silicon Valley. Viewed with disdain by most of their fellow interns, Billy and Nick join forces with the rest of the misfit “nooglers” to make it through a series of competitive team challenges.

This movie reflects a little insight into the unconscious biases we all have when it comes to hiring in a hilariously funny way. Ageism, degree discrimination, and discrimination when it comes to candidates that were recently fired or laid off. The following scene shows a recruiters biggest fear when it comes to video interviews.

 

 

Up in the Air (2009)

An idea from a young, new co-worker would put an end to the constant travel of corporate downsizer Ryan Bingham, so he takes her on a tour to demonstrate the importance of face-to-face meetings with those they must fire. While mentoring his colleague, he arranges hookups with another frequent-flier, and his developing feelings for the woman prompt him to see others in a new light.

For recruiters, it is a reminder that we are working with people – not just ‘candidates.’ A person’s career is a part of them. It is a scary prospect to leave a position that they are comfortable with. That is why when you recruit a candidate to go to another job, you need to make sure that without a doubt, the new job you are placing them in is truly a job that can meet the candidate’s needs – not just yours.

 

Boiler Room (2000) 

Desperate to please his father who is federal judge, Seth Davis, an ambitious, intelligent college dropout gets a job as a stockbroker for a small firm. Lured by big commissions and dreams of wealth, he becomes very successful at sales, but comes to question the legitimacy of his firm’s operations.

This movie is a little harsh, but there are some key points to pay attention to. Things like knowing as much information as possible before approaching a candidate. Understand that the more people you contact, the greater chance there is to find the perfect candidate. As a recruiter, you are a part of a team that includes hiring manager, interviewers, Human Resources, and candidates. As part of that team, if you put your interests over what the entire needs of the team are, you will fail as a recruiter.

 

https://youtu.be/qhmZSHOCOCw

Glengarry Glen Ross (1992)

Adapted from the Pulitzer Prize-winning play by David Mamet, the film focuses on four desperate real estate agents who sell investment properties in retirement developments. Under corporate pressure to increase performance, they are forced to compete in a sales contest. Since the losers will be fired, the agents resort to treachery to fool potential clients. All of the sales professionals are fighting for a list of leads to close their next deal.

Let’s face it. Recruiting can be a tough deal. But if you try to find an easy way out or depend just on technology to find candidates, you will not be successful. Don’t take shortcuts. Recruiting has always been and will always be a people business.

 

 

We would list more, but this is called ‘The Five’ not the ten. What are your choices for movies all recruiters must watch? Put your choices in the list below.

Employee Engagement: You’re A Phony. I Said It. Now What?

In life, there are times when you are part of conversations that make you roll your eyes so far back into your head that the possibility of a seizure looms. Such as, which hot sauce is the hottest in the world. No one cares because I’m not interested in setting fire to my mouth in stages. Or, how badly you slept last night. Telling me you woke up at 2 am, 3 am, 4:30 am and then at 6 am is not making me feel sympathetic for you, it’s making me want to throat punch you for subjecting me to this conversation. Or even how much your child is eating and how they’ve moved on to solid foods. Unless the food is going in my mouth, I couldn’t give a shit about what your baby is eating.

Hot Sauce and Baby Talk. Employee Engagement Is A Lesson In Human Behavior.

In business, these types of conversations happen every single day and you find yourself dragged into meeting rooms to discuss the banal, the bizarre and the downright ridiculous. Like what processes we’re going to implement to keep the stationary cupboard clean, or a breakdown of the spreadsheet that tracks other spreadsheets. Most recently, I’ve been dragged into numerous conversations about employee engagement and how to create it. I sit there listening to people present what they think are genius solutions to pissed off employees all while trying to make it into a business art form.

Employee engagement is nothing but a lesson in human behavior. This isn’t a science that needs metrics and tools and apps and god knows what else you want to throw at it because you can’t figure out why Janice in strategy isn’t happier even though you’ve promised her a pay rise in twelve months’ time. This doesn’t need hours of meetings between the board as they try to figure out how to get a better rating on Glassdoor because they’re probably the most disconnected from their employees anyway. And it certainly doesn’t need the thousands of blogs that currently pollute the internet and are labeled something like ‘5 tips to create employee engagement’.

You cannot create employee engagement. It isn’t something that happens as a result of the free fruit bowl you placed in the kitchen. You just have to not be a dick. That’s literally it. It’s that simple. And that’s a lesson that all senior members of staff need to take on, and maybe then they’d understand why their Glassdoor reviews are so shit. Employees might dislike each other, teams might not always get on and there will always be personality clashes within the walls of organizations, but it is the peacocking of senior members of staff that cause dissatisfied and disengaged employees.

Six Months Without Caring?

I know this because I’ve been a disengaged employee many times. Once I was so disengaged I managed to not do any work for six whole months. SIX WHOLE MONTHS! That’s an impressive stretch and testament to what pricks my senior management team were. I didn’t get to that point because Dan in the perm recruitment team won’t pull his weight, I got to that point because management handled themselves badly and with all the grace of a floundering fish.

We’re living in a completely changed world. Technology has altered everything, the way we communicate is different and no one gives a hoot about a hierarchy anymore. Which is not to say one isn’t needed, but managers and leaders and bosses and whatever else they want to call themselves need to be aware that they haven’t been anointed by God and this isn’t the Third Fucking Reich. This is something the recruitment world painfully struggles with, mainly because it’s an industry that absolutely fails to grasp the concept of humility.

Just as business has had to adapt and evolve to prosper in this modern world, so too must leaders and their management style. You don’t get to be ‘better than’. There are times you’ll inevitably be being a dick and someone should be able to call you out on it without ending up in HR.

10 Keys To Amazing Employee Engagement:

  1. Talk to me like I’m a fellow human because your demands have a touch of the slave trade about them.
  2. Actually, talk to me and find out what’s going on with me so you understand a bigger picture.
  3. Get to know me and take the time to learn what works and what doesn’t.
  4. Understand that it’s your job to get the best out of me not the most.
  5. Don’t talk about your money struggles because your position means we automatically don’t give a fuck.
  6. Be humble because your bragging rights were revoked the minute you became a ‘superior’.
  7. Know that a title isn’t a shield against being a total wanker.
  8. Do what you said you would and don’t back out of things.
  9. If you make a promise always keep it, and if you can’t, don’t make promises.
  10. In short, don’t be a dickhead.

Skip The Almond Milk. I Need “Grade A” $h*t.

The rules with which we build personal relationships should always be applied when you’re in a position of authority. All the ways you wouldn’t act with friends or lovers, shouldn’t then be brought into the office. We don’t need conferences on employee engagement and whitepapers on the tips to building an engaged workforce. We don’t even need the free almond milk in the fridge or the Spotify memberships. We just need management to get off their god damn high horse and realize that they heyday of horrible bosses is over and that’s not how you treat people anymore. Understand that and you’ll realize that employee engagement is just another wanky business buzzword that people like to throw around to sound special.

 

About the Author: Salma El-Wardany, Head of Marketing, Recruitment Entrepreneur cut her teeth in recruitment at a global Plc, Salma El-Wardanyworking in business development to win new clients and accounts into the company. She gave up corporate life in favor of the startup world, specifically recruitment startups.

Salma spends her days advising recruitment companies on their marketing, digital and branding strategies, and how to make their voice heard in an industry that is already overcrowded and full of voices clamoring to be heard. By night, she writes about many things, mainly all the things in recruitment that vex her.

Check out her blog, The Chronicles of Salma or connect with her on LinkedIn.