Sure. the lack of supply and cutthroat competition for in-demand skills may be partly to blame for your hiring woes, it’s too often used as a convenient scapegoat for the much more significant problems with recruiting processes and policies that are largely to blame for most employers’ hiring challenges and “talent detraction” woes.
Before blaming the bigger economic picture, throwing a ton of money at talent technology, recruiting systems or the next shiny sourcing or SaaS solution to come along or simply resigning yourself to the B Team instead of continuing to find, attract and hire truly top talent, there are some pretty obvious things every employer should look at fixing, first.
5 Reasons You’re Not Finding the Best Candidates.
4. You Don’t Care What Your Candidates Have To Say.
The problem with these traditional screening methods, however, is that they often don’t tell the whole story about what a person is really like, or what they’re capable of in the future.
Fact is, most recruiting related documentation focuses squarely on what a candidate has already done. This means we’re hiring people based on the past instead of their potential, which is a potentially fatal flaw in many recruiting processes.
To really get a true sense of any candidate’s skills and personality, you’ve got to go past their profiles, resumes, cover letters or that staid, static, traditional stuff recruiters have relied on for far too long.
If you’re not hearing their voices, shut up and listen. Because candidates have a ton to tell you, if you’re willing to actually hear what it is they have to say (and how they say it, too).
A new study conducted by researchers at the University of Chicago found that when recruiters listened to job candidates’ qualifications, they rated them as more competent than those whose qualifications they read — even when the words were the same. The results showed recruiters liked these candidates more and were more likely to hire them.
Make your screening process more personal with phone or video screening interviews. And most important of all: let them tell you their own story, in their own voice. That way, you can figure out if it’s worth working together on that next chapter or not. Forget resumes. This is what real recruiting is really all about.
3. You’re Making It Harder Than It Has To Be.
We talk a lot about candidate experience, but the fact of the matter is that many employers have to strike a balance between making the application, screening, interviewing and selection processes as painless as possible with getting to know enough about a candidate’s experience and aspirations to make the right choice when extending an offer.
Screening tools, behavioral or group interviews, assessment technologies or other solutions might be great ways to get to know more about candidates, but using too many can kill your chances at scoring top talent.
Requiring candidates to jump through hoops before hiring them makes the process long and difficult, and they’re likely to accept another offer before they reach your final interview stage.
In fact, the LinkedIn survey found that 44 percent of respondents took less than a month to search for and accept a new job. If your hiring process is too long, you could lose the best candidates to your competition.
What’s more, a survey conducted by CareerBuilder found that 58 percent of employers surveyed said they don’t communicate with applicants about how long the interview or application process will take. If your multi-stage interview process drags on without an end in sight, candidates are bound to get frustrated and look for another opportunity.
Let candidates know what to expect from your hiring process, and don’t make it any longer and more complicated than it needs to be.
2. You Can’t Make Up Your Damned Mind.
You’ve made it through the hiring process and you’ve decided on the candidate you want to hire. But before you make an offer, you need to iron out the details, get the offer approved, and get feedback on your choice to make sure you’ve selected the best candidate for the job.
In fact, the CareerBuilder survey found that 38 percent of employers wait more than three days after the interview to extend a job offer to a candidate. In that time, your perfect candidate is losing interest and searching for other opportunities.
If you find the right candidate, send them an offer as soon as possible. The longer you wait, the more likely it is they’ve moved on. Because sometimes, getting recruiting right means getting it “right now.”
1. Your Offers Are A Joke.
According to the CareerBuilder survey, 18 percent of candidates surveyed rejected the initial job offer extended to them by their current employers, successfully holding out to negotiate for a more lucrative package, higher salary, better bonuses or benefits or some combination thereof.
Here’s the thing: if we all agree that our people are our greatest assets, you need to be willing to pay the premium top talent commands and put your money where your mouth is.
By Josh Tolan
Josh Tolan is the CEO of Spark Hire, a video interview solution used by more than 4,000 companies across the globe.
Weekly news and industry insights delivered straight to your inbox.