5 Ways to Recruit for a Company That Sucks

Have an article to share? Submit it to our editorial team!

Submit Article

A recruiter is a cheerleader for the company. You are trying to recruit the best team, and encouraging them to join because you know that this position at this company is a possibility of a lifetime. So how do you recruit for a company that at one time had the reputation of being as “The 11 Worst Companies to Work for in America!

Read Between the Lines

During the discovery process, candidates will give you the answers to the test. When during your screenings, are you noting the red flags? Did you check references? While there are always exceptions, here are things that candidates bring up that in my experience has always turned out in disaster for companies with poor reps:

  • Asking about vacation and benefits before asking about the company or the position. (Don’t get me wrong: benefits, especially health, are extremely important, and should be discussed early, but not earlier than the company and the job.)
  • Candidates who have not heard of your company or have not done any research on the company culture or employees
  • Candidates who come in with a plan to revamp the entire company before starting.
  • Desperate, I-will-do-anything candidates.
  • Candidates who want work/life balance. In crappy companies, there is either no balance or their policies are too lax (aka no one seems to be working.)

Stop Recruiting Bad Candidates

As a recruiter, you are of the reason people think the company you work for sucks. Think about it, aren’t you the one submitting crappy candidates to hiring managers?   Your job as a recruiter is to find the perfect candidate for your company. Skills are 25%. The other 75% falls under soft skills, personality, work ethic, environment, and whether or not the candidate would be a good cultural fit. Stop trying to force square pegs into round holes. Once you hire enough candidates who actually fit in with your company culture, the attitudes of employees and the external perception will change.

You Lied to Me!

Be honest. The odds are the reputation of your company is no big secret. When you are an agency recruiter, you can tell them what you have heard on the streets. When you are a corporate recruiter, you hear about it (and take it) every day. Let candidates know that you know what the reputation is, and if possible, let them know why you think it exists. The worst thing you can do is sweep it under the rug only to have the employee you just hired leave with contempt toward the company.

Let candidates know the situation as best one can, and allow them to make their choice with their eyes wide open. The candidate who did not get the all of the information necessary to make an educated discussion before joining your organization could very well prevent you from getting your next opportunity. Hell has no fury like an employee scorned!

“Papa Was a Rolling Stone”

Look for candidates with a consulting background. Most consultants cannot stand being in an overly structured environment. Consultants go from company to company fixing what internal employees could not achieve on their own. They are used to going into crazy environments who are crying out for help. Companies with bad reputations are looking for a hero! Get a candidate with the right fit and you are both heroes!

How Come You Never See a Headline Like “Psychic Wins Lottery?”

How do you know that potential candidates will not want to work there? I learned early in my recruiting career not to try to be a psychic. Who am I decide that you won’t like the position being offered. They could love the company! There are people who thrive on stress and chaos. Make sure they have the information but if they say they would love it, let them.

At the end of the day make sure that when someone leaves the company, it isn’t because of something you tried to hide. We are dealing with people’s livelihoods here. If the candidate who you find only has the skill set, but none of the other important factors needed to succeed, keep recruiting. Recruiting is a verb. Keep recruiting until you find the ideal candidate for your company.

If you Don’t Know, Now you Knowbiggie_2

  • Make sure you have an environment that invites employees to share their opinions, both positive and negative. If possible, have the CEO or other top executive address the concern in the company newsletters.
  • Don’t forget retention! You should be getting updates on how employees feel while they are still engaged, not
    when they are walking out the door. (By then, it is too late.) Have candid conversations with top performers. Find out why people are staying and work that into your pitch. Have your story ready. If the company stinks so badly, why did you accept a position there?
  • Take a look at Glassdoor and other websites where employees review where they work, but take it with a grain of salt. See what is being said on the street about your company, but realize that these are anonymous reviews mostly done by people ask to leave the company being reviewed.

The top things that people complain about are:

  • The Money Sucks
  • The Commute Sucks
  • Their Boss Sucks
  • The Chances of Getting a Promotion Sucks
  • Their Co-workers Suck
  • The Work/Life Balance Sucks
  • Their Office Space Sucks
  • No cafeteria or nearby food options ( OK I made this one up…)

There is only so much you can do to change the reputation of your company. Stick to your morals and principals. Don’t sell you soul to the devil. Be honest and the truth will set you free. Just keep recruiting.

About the Author: Jackye Clayton is recognized as a people expert who puts the Human in Human Resources.Jackye Clayton Contributing Editor Recruiting Tools An international trainer, she has traveled worldwide sharing her unique gifts in sourcing, recruiting and coaching. She offers various dynamic presentations on numerous topics related to leadership development, inclusionary culture development, team building and more.Her in-depth experience in working with top Fortune and Inc 500 clients and their employees has allowed her to create customized programs to coach, train and recruit top talent and inspire others to greatness. Follow Jackye on Twitter@JackyeClayton or connect with her on LinkedIn.

By Jackye Clayton

Jackye Clayton, with acclaimed expertise in diversity and inclusion, recruitment technology and a global network of non-profit, human resource and recruiting professionals, Jackye Clayton is a servant leader, uniquely inspirational speaker, and a revered thought leader. Jackye was named one of the 9 Powerful Women in Business You Should Know by SDHR Consulting, one of the 15 Women in HR Tech to Follow in 2019 by VidCruiter, 2019 Top 100 list of Human Resources Influencers by Human Resource Executive Magazine and one of the Top Recruitment Thought Leaders that you must follow in 2019 by interviewMocha Magazine. Currently, Jackye is the Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Strategist at SeekOut. You can find her on Twitter @jackyeclayton and LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/jackyeclayton

Latest News

Fountain Adds Integration With Payments Platform Branch

Fountain, which provides an ATS and hiring automation software for the frontline workforce, launched an integration with workforce payments platform Branch. It’s the first integrated payments solution on Fountain’s platform…. Read more

Job Seekers See AI As More Biased than People

A significant minority of employed job seekers say AI recruiting tools are more biased than than the people using them, according to a Harris Poll survey conducted on behalf of… Read more

HCM Talent Technology Roundup September 15, 2023

Justworks will acquire the international employment platform Via with the aim of increasing SMB access to the global talent pool. The acquisition will incorporate Via’s capabilities into Justworks’ existing suite… Read more


Chipotle’s Hiring Surge: What Happens After Burrito Season?


Did you know that spring is officially Burrito Season? It is, according to the folks at Chipotle who say their busiest time of year is from March to May. Chipotle… Read more

Breaking: Amazon is Laying Off 10,000 Employees


According to company insiders, employees of Amazon are being told the company plans to slash up to 10,000 employees. It is not known at this time if that number is… Read more

Recruit Holdings Releases Q2 Earnings


Recruit Holdings, the Japanese parent-company of Indeed and Glassdoor, has released its quarterly earnings report. Overall the numbers are strong, both from a revenue perspective as well as engagement. Indeed… Read more


Don’t Panic! Navigating AI in Recruitment

Join us at this can’t-miss event as we explore recruiting’s unfolding future with AI.

Be part of HRTX on September 28, 2023, and learn how to harness AI’s potential without losing the human touch.